If you liked it then you should have put a ring on it
If you liked it then you shoulda put a ring on it
Don't be mad once you see that he want it
If you liked it then you shoulda put a ring on it.
First things first: my disclaimer.
I admit that it's got a great beat and an awesome dance. And naturally that's going to be what people say to me after this post, as a justification for listening to this song and singing along. So there, I said it. It's catchy.
I admit that it's got a great beat and an awesome dance. And naturally that's going to be what people say to me after this post, as a justification for listening to this song and singing along. So there, I said it. It's catchy.
However, if you're in a room with any number of girls> 1 and this song comes on, there becomes this tangible aura of "girl power." Why is that? It's not because of the beat. It's not because of the dance. It's because of the lyrics. Beyonce (who has already thrown away my respect as a person: see lyrics of Survivor versus lyrics of Naughty Girl) is proclaiming that ohhh, "I'm so fine that you better marry me if you wanna keep another guy from snatching me up." I mean in essence, this is what she's saying. Even though that's a pretty arrogant thing to say, that's not where my dispute lies.
Ladies...
I need you to be realistic with me for just a moment. Please reflect on this long enough to consider your actual response, and do not just brush it off as an exaggerated scenario with all these "well it depends" excuses. That's all bullcrap. Imagine for a few minutes if this actually happened to you: you're dancing in the club with some guy you just started dating/seeing/whatevering and the fool actually drops to a knee, whips out a ring, and proposes to you? I mean he's just doing as the song commands, is he not? That's sweet, isn't it? I mean I'm sure that every single lady in the joint would be very excited to suddenly be not single, right? NO! You would freak the heck out! Unless you've been dating this dude seriously (aka you're in a relationship, aka you're not single so this song doesn't even apply to you so why do you sing it with such self-empowered feminism?), you will scream OMG CREEPER and run off, avoiding the boy every day for the rest of your life.
So it's just ironic to me to hear girls sing this song with so much authority. If you're single because you like being single, then don't sing a song about how a man better commit if he wants to keep you around. If you're single because you're waiting for Mr. Right, don't sing a song with the misguided message that any guy that wants to keep you better give you a ring, and quick! But if you're single against your will, by all means sing this song with all your heart. Just don't slap the guy that jumps the gun on a proposal.
I will make an exception for my usual "do not respond to comments" policy and debate freely, if public comments are made that justify it. :-)
Disclaimer edit: This blog addresses the message that the chorus presents. Taken in context with the verses, the message is for women in long-term relationships with guys that won't commit to forever. Which is a pretty good message. But my aim is to shut up the ridiculousness of the many girls who ignore the verses and only get excited over the chorus.

